The Sunday Telegraph
Christopher Booker's Notebook
The rigging of a referendum
The forthcoming referendum on an elected regional government for the North-East is generally dismissed by the media as just a "local story". This is their loss, however, for not only do they miss its far-reaching national implications, they are losing an opportunity to report on a fascinating political soap opera.
Last week, as the campaign got under way, John Prescott's Office of the Deputy Prime Minister ended up with egg all over its face. It had to admit to putting out an inaccurate - and possibly illegal - leaflet: an error that it plans to rectify by issuing a further document that may also be illegal.
Then there was the curious way that the Electoral Commission chose to accredit one of the two rival "No" campaigns that could have been eligible to receive Government funding, in defiance of its own officials' advice and in a way that plays into the hands of Mr Prescott's "Yes" campaign.
For two years, the opposition in the fight against Mr Prescott's proposed assembly has been led by the "North East No" campaign run by and Neil Herron, a Sunderland businessman. This group has a successful track record, not least in getting the Audit Commission to declare as illegal payments made by 25 local authorities to a body set up to issue propaganda for the elected assembly.
Two months ago, however, another group, "North East Says No", entered the arena. Originally masterminded from London by the Conservative Party, its main (and useful) achievement has been to win endorsement from a phalanx of local business leaders (including John Elliott, formerly chairman of the other "No" campaign).
Run and staffed by Tories, the group has no track record and its grasp of the issues appears to be minimal. When applications were made to the Electoral Commission for official "designation", those responsible for examining the applications concluded that Herron's group better met the criteria.
Yet when the commission met last Monday to decide, their advice was overruled. On Tuesday, Mr Prescott thus had the best news he could have hoped for: the designation - and £100,000 of taxpayers' money - went to a campaign run by a party now so weak in the North-East region that it has only one MP.
If the referendum could be presented as a party battle, with a "No" campaign identified with the Conservatives (plus the UK Independence Party), this would be Mr Prescott's best chance of snatching victory against all odds.
As Mr Elliott shook hands with a visibly relieved Professor John Tomaney, the leader of the "Yes" campaign, after the announcement, it was scarcely a promising start. The North East Says No spokesman, a former Tory candidate, claimed that the campaigners were not opposed to an elected assembly in principle, and that if such an assembly were given more powers, they might support it.
Despite this setback, Mr Herron and his supporters are fighting on as a "people's campaign". Meanwhile, the shambles that Mr Prescott has made of his own campaign is compounded by the Government's admission that it made a serious factual error in its propaganda leaflet, Your Say, recently sent to every North-East voter, by seriously understating the cost of setting up a unitary local authority in Durham.
The ODPM now plans to issue a "clarification" letter, but only to voters in County Durham - even though its earlier statement was sent to all 1.9 million voters, most of whom will thus be voting on the basis of what Mr Prescott's deputy, Nick Raynsford, admitted last Wednesday was erroneous information.
The ODPM knows that it is barred from sending out information during the 28 days before a referendum, but as its own website shows, this period ends 28 days before ballot papers go out on October 18, not, as the ODPM is now pretending, 28 days before polling day (November 4).
Furthermore, the ODPM's leaflet (which was not submitted for vetting to the Electoral Commission) is now the subject of investigation because of two, still more serious, errors.
First, it claims that elections to the new assembly will be by proportional representation, although the Regional Assemblies Bill makes clear that two-thirds of the seats will be "first past the post".
It also claims that the assembly will be wholly independent of central government, when the Bill makes clear that in crucial respects it will be subject to Government control.
On Thursday, a formal complaint about these errors was lodged with the Audit Commission and the Electoral Commission by Mr Herron's "North East No" campaign. If this is upheld, it seems that, with only six weeks to go, Mr Prescott could face his biggest embarrassment yet.
- ► 2011 (51)
- ► 2010 (174)
- ► 2009 (115)
- ► 2008 (179)
- ► 2007 (210)
- ► 2006 (392)
- ► 2005 (445)
- Latest Poll...59% of Chronicle Readers Say No
- Press Release
- 'Foot in Mouth' disease flares up again
- Parents hold power balance Sep 30 2004 By Graeme...
- Calls start coming in...from Conservatives
- Letter Writers Exposed...Undercover Elephants
- More rows in the Counties and Districts
- Letters exposing misrepresentation cover the regio...
- NECC Poll rattles Yes Campaign into desperatesvill...
- More evidence of a stitch up
- Today's Letters
- NESNO Say No
- Journal Letters
- Assembly proposals 'half-baked' Sep 24 2004 By E...
- Sunday Telegraph Letters Date: 26 September 2004 ...
- North East's Biggest City Says No
- More bad news for Yes
- Prescott now exposed as desperate
- The full press release from NECC
- Northern Echo Business bosses reject N-E assembly...
- Another nail in the Yes Campaign coffin
- National Coverage as stakes get higher
- Judicial Review Papers Lodged
- Liberal Party Chairman calls for a No vote
- Tony Blair and Gordon Brown unite to say 'No'
- Yes Campaign kicked again by business
- ...while the official campaign sat on its hands
- North East Small Business not impressed with Presc...
- No Campaign takes the Deputy Prime Minister to Hig...
- Newcastle Evening Chronicle
- Today's Letters
- What price information? What price democracy?
- Lib Dems Say Government "Fumbled" and "stuttered"
- Northern Echo 23rd September... Councils take Lega...
- Regional Organisers Letters
- Sunderland Echo News 23rd September
- NESNO gets a headline! Well done.
- Moe correspondence from the public
- Audit Commission adds nothing ;-)
- ODPM Ask for more time
- High noon for Raynsford
- We want answers from the Electoral Commission, not...
- North East Says No Campaign Responds to the Questi...
- 27 hours and counting...Yes Campaign still silent ...
- More Letters...tidal wave grows
- Emergency Meetings in the Electoral Commission
- Ante Raised...Court case looms
- What are the Tories saying No to, and are they say...
- Spotlight getting brighter...Electoral Commssion g...
- Public waking up to the stitch-up
- Conspiracy over Stitch-up Grows
- 24 Hours and Counting
- Complaints start going in to the Electoral Commiss...
- Stakes raised and ODPM on the back foot
- Electoral Commission catch 'Foot in Mouth'
- 'Foot in Mouth' Epidemic Spreads
- 'Foot in Mouth' outbreak in North East
- Liberals attack Electoral Commission decision
- Prescott Looking for a Court Appearance
- Legal Challenge...Complaint to the Electoral Commi...
- Legal Challenge...Complaint to ODPM
- The Legal Challenge...Audit Commission Complaint
- The Rigging of a Referendum
- The Electoral Commissioners
- As more worms leave the tin
- NESNO walking into punch after punch
- Conspiracy over designation grows
- Shambles now about to become absolute chaos
- Undecided? Yes or No? More champagne Sir?
- Discredited Electoral Commission and the Betrayal ...
- Another Cock-up by the now discredited Electoral C...
- Just to Refresh you
- Electoral Commission about to be discredited?
- Who knew NESNO were the No Campaign?
- Mallon Ponders Role In Assembly
- Constituencies Decided ...after a Yes vote
- What have they done? Its now Conservative vs Labou...
- Electoral Commission Decides
- Rural Communities uncertain over benefits of an As...
- Cross and Non Party Coalition
- More Outrageous claims by Prescott
- There is nothing like a dose of self-interest to s...
- Recent Letters
- Regional Assemblies entering their twilight years....
- "Me? A cynic? Is it not obvious?"
- "We are giving you a referendum you never asked fo...
- A Collection of Recent Letters
- Prescott's Propaganda Challenged
- Whoops they did it again! BBC use Labour Politicia...
- Prescott running scared
- Well Done John Taylor, Leader of Alnwick Council
- What was \the question?
- Bottled Fog Sellers Lose out to Free Bread
- Tidal Wave of opposition
- Simply ask the question..."Why does there need to ...
- Spotlight getting brighter on this outrageous frau...
- ▼ September (96)